Andy on Twitter

  • Really, directly in the middle of the biggest city in Australia and two bars from and NBN that is gl… ,
  • Great piece of writing ... The Forgotten Legend of Silicon Valley’s Flying Saucer Man ,
  • Cardinal Pell, top advisor to Pope Francis, found guilty of ‘historical sexual offenses’ | America Magazine ,
  • Never buy a Miele appliance. Service levels are appalling. @MieleAustralia,
  • A Primer on Digital Humans by @soulmachines,
  • OK ... that's a quote to ponder: "In today's economy, innovation means elegant theft: robbery of your data, privacy… ,
  • Great read for all of you suffering from . ,
  • The wall of advertising on Facebook is getting ridiculous. On mobile every third thumb stroke yields another nearl… ,
  • If never ceases to amaze me the inane crap people will suggest marketing is about. What BS. Seth is better than th… ,
  • That could be it. Yikes. ,
  • Sad to see Rapha close in Sydney. They’ll loose the community and fans. And all that ransom shopping. That’s the i… ,
  • For all those upset that RL positions itself as a US company with NZ roots, this is why. Access to massive amounts… ,
  • Getting served ads -like that promoting the Apple App Store - and reconciling that with digital marketing’s claims… ,
  • When Mark says this I don’t think he is blaming anyone, just speaking the truth. “The biggest lesson from this year… ,
  • Another year. Another brilliant Ad. They've got some magic going here... ,
  • Learned

Perhaps they got the store concept wrong

Interesting read on Bloomberg about retailers shuttering their Facebook stores. What’s surprising is that they didn’t try new concepts all together. Why would you shop the same experience in Facebook that you could have on the web? If the alternate store is one bookmarked click away, then there is hardly stickiness.

We’ve had an alternate experience at CBA – the Facebook community is vibrant and its an exciting channel. We don’t want another branch in Facebook, we want Facebook to be an extension of our branches. For the two together, to create a better and differentiated experience. Ok, it’s early days. And that’s why shuttering stores seems remarkably shortsighted. 

It also seems to miss one of the killer elements that Facebook offers us all – a compelling and low-cost platform on which to experience and play. Play is the key factor. It is what people do when they get there. I wonder how many of these retailers tried to reinvent retailing as a game in facebook? 

We’d give Facebook an “F” for fun, and and “A” for marketing impact.

One Response

  1. By Kenneth on February 26th, 2012 at 7:28 pm

    Hi Andy,
    I admire your attitude toward Facebook!
    It is interesting how an FB wall can become a service portal for some businesses – however for financial services (and any business that has privacy issues in service delivery) it isn’t possible to actually provide substantive service contact there, so the portal can become more of a ‘service quality complaints portal’. CBA is brave and honest the way they manage that in the open.
    Any thoughts about keeping a good mix on the wall and managing it toward the positive, while avoiding too much self-promo posting that turns people away? And can you share any impression about how many eyes are attracted to your ‘fun’ tools vs the wall?

Speak Up — Add Your Thoughts

Connections

  • Learned
How did you connect?   [?]
Indulgences-Coffee